The world of antique putters is one where expert knowledge pays off
for both serious collectors and first-time buyer. We spoke to two experts in the field - Graham Griffiths
antiquehickorygolfclubs.com and Gavin Bottrell of
antiquegolfclub.co.uk to get the inside track on what to
look for when buying a wooden-headed or metal-headed hickory putter.
Free Strokes Gained Calculator
Find out how well you putt and where to improve!
Join our putting tips email list and get a free Strokes Gained Calculator.
The calculator lets you see how well you putt in comparison with PGA Tour pros and where you can improve. “Thanks to your tips, I've reduced my putting numbers from the high 40s per round to the high 30s in just 5 rounds and haven't had a 3-putt green in two rounds! I've literally cut 10 shots off my putting game in 3 weeks!” Elliot, 25 handicap
Your calculator and first putting technique email is on its way to you now.
Best-Putter.com: What should you look for when buying an antique
Graham Griffiths: It really depends what you want it for. Are you hanging
it on the wall or are you a hickory player looking to find that perfect putter?
In both cases condition is important, but you can get away with more serious
issues - like a crack in a hickory shaft - if you're only going to display the putter
rather than use it.
... on an antique putter
Not in the US? Click here for eBay listings for an antique putter in your region
B-P: And if you're looking to play with it?
GG: Then it's a question of feel. Most players have to buy and try quite
a number of older putters to find one they're really happy with. The feel of
antique putters is far more variable than modern putters, so you really cannot
tell how a putter will play until you have it in your hands. Most serious
hickory players have quite a large number of putters!
B-P: How easy are they to repair?
GG: Restoration of an old putter is not that easy. A really good job
takes time, skill and care. Removing rust without excessively marking the head
is the main challenge. This can be done with rust remover and sand paper, but
the best way is using a grinding machine. If you want to maintain the putter's
value it's important not to remove or distort the headmaker's name (known as a
cleekmark). Sourcing and then winding on an authentic grip also takes a bit of
time. That having been said, there are excellent antique club restorers in the
UK, Sweden, USA, Switzerland and Germany. If anyone needs help, they should get
in touch with me at
B-P: Which are the most valuable antique or hickory putters?
GG: Collectors value wooden-headed putters of the Tom Morris era
(pre-1905) as the most valuable category of old putters, especially the
long-nose mallets. If they're in good condition, these sell for around £500 ($800-850). Mostly, though these putters aren't in great condition because the
heads generally have lots of marks in them. Putters in exceptional condition -
especially those with a story attached to them - can attract international
interest and sell for more as a result.
B-P: What should you do if you have a putter to sell?
GG: It depends what sort of putter you have. If you're pretty sure it's
not valuable, then eBay provides the best market, but if you think it might be
worth something then you're best off either sending in pictures to a site like
mine and we'll give you an appraisal or taking it to a local auction room where
you'll be able to get a rough valuation.
B-P: What if I wanted to buy a specific model, such as a Bobby Locke
GG: You're best bet here is to search on Google. You'll most likely find
the putter you're looking for in an auction house listing or on a specialist website. For a Pay-off putter, you'd expect to pay £120-130 ($200).
B-P: What should you look for when buying online, without seeing
the club first?
GG: The most important thing is to ask about the seller some questions
about the condition of the club, particularly the condition of the shaft.
Hickory shafts split easily, especially in hot climates, so knowing where the
club has been kept during its lifetime can be a good guide to the condition of
the shaft. Also it's a good idea to ask whether the head is loose. Even a slight
bit of movement between the head and shaft will most likely mean that the putter
B-P: Finally, what does it feel like to play with a good antique putter?
GG: The feel is terrific with a good hickory shafted putter. Since
they're almost all heel-shafted, they rely far more on balance than modern
clubs, but once you get a good quality putter in your hands, I don't think you'd
see any discernable difference between your results with an antique and a modern
putter. Some of the modern designs seem very clumsy and brick-like by